Should I Rent a Car in St. Thomas? The Pros and Cons for Hotel 1829 Guests

Hotel 1829
Apr 18
2 min read

Planning a trip to St. Thomas and staying at Hotel 1829 in charming downtown Charlotte Amalie? One of the biggest questions travelers face is whether to rent a car during their stay. The answer depends on your itinerary, comfort level with driving on the island, and how much you plan to explore beyond the downtown area.

Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons to help you decide.

Why You Might Not Need a Rental Car

1. Hotel 1829’s Prime Walkable Location

Our historic hotel is nestled in the heart of Charlotte Amalie, where you’ll find:

Restaurants & Bars – Many dining options are just steps away.
Shopping & Boutiques – From local crafts to luxury goods, you can explore on foot.
Waterfront Views – A short stroll takes you to the harbor for sunset walks.

2. Affordable & Adventurous Public Transportation

St. Thomas has a unique and budget-friendly transit system:

Safari Buses – These open-air "Safaris" follow set routes across the island for just a few dollars per ride. They’re a fun way to travel like a local!
Taxis – Readily available for direct trips to beaches or attractions.

3. No Parking Hassles

Downtown parking can be limited, and navigating steep, narrow roads may be stressful for unfamiliar drivers. Skipping a rental means no parking fees or worries.

When Renting a Car Makes Sense

1. You Want to Explore Remote Beaches & Hidden Gems

While public transit covers main areas, a rental car gives you freedom to visit:

Secret coves like Lindquist Beach or Hull Bay
Scenic overlooks like Drake’s Seat or Mountain Top
The quieter shores of the north side of the island

2. You Prefer Flexibility & Privacy

While Safaris run on "island time," taxis are generally more reliable and prompt. However, a rental car lets you move at your own pace—no waiting, no schedules, just pure freedom to explore.

3. You’re Comfortable Driving Mountainous Roads

St. Thomas is hilly, with winding, steep roads (remember: we drive on the left!). If you’re confident navigating challenging terrain, renting could enhance your trip.

The Verdict? It Depends on Your Stay!

For a relaxed, downtown-centric vacation → Skip the rental and enjoy walking + Safaris/taxis.
For adventurers exploring the whole island → A rental car may be worth it.

No matter what you choose, Hotel 1829 is your perfect home base—close to the action yet a peaceful retreat. Have questions? Ask our staff for personalized tips!